- The US Virgin Islands Best Guide
St. Thomas Restaurants
Staff & Service
Party of 2 attended on "All you can eat" U Peel Shrimp Night, Thursday.. We were seated immediately outside for 6 pm reservations. Beautiful view. After 15 minutes, Jerry, who seated us, asked, "Has anyone taken your order?" When we replied, "No" he said he would be our waiter. Ordered the free drinks offered through our hotel, the rum punch was watered down. My spouse ordered the lobster, listed at $25.00 per pound. It was delicious. We had to ask for water, halfway through the meal. It was never refilled. I ordered the shrimp. The table next to ours had additional shrimp delivered four times. We had to wait forever, and received only one refill, while tables immediately adjacent to us with the same waiter (as well as waitresses) were visited numerous times. The key lime pie was still frozen. Had to wait another 15 minutes for cappuccino to arrive although it was ordered with the key lime pie. It was coffee with milk added, no froth, no cinnamon. The table was cleared of dinner dishes, but plates with the shrimp shells remained until dessert arrived. We would return, but ask for a waitress who has better reviews.