Water Island, located within St. Thomas’ Charlotte Amalie harbor, is a 491.5 acre treasure. The small population of fewer than 200 full and part time residents enjoy the tranquility of a largely commercial free island while having the conveniences of developed St. Thomas only a 10 minute boat/ferry ride away.

Water Island’s real estate market is small and fairly exclusive. The real estate possibilities are very limited in quantity due to the island’s small size and to a low turnover rate.

Approximately 100 homes dot the hills and valleys of Water Island. Most lots and homes offer a view of the ocean and many also have a view of neighboring St. Thomas and Hassel Island. Presently, April 2019, there are 15 listings on the Water Island real estate market.

There are 11 houses currently listed. They range from a 2-bedroom 2-bath house on .1 acre for $299,000; to a 1-bedroom 1 bath on 1.35 acres for $695,000; to 2.9 million for a 14-bedroom 7 bath on 2.42 acres waterfront lot in a private estate.

Properties with only a cistern and foundation do become available from time to time.

There is one condo development on Water Island however currently there isn’t any available units on the market.

Currently there are 4 land lots listed. Lots range from $139,000 to $250,000 for 1 acre; to 1.1 million for 1.76 acres.

Foreclosures are non-existent on Water Island. Residents, for the most part, own their homes outright. Sale of any property for outstanding taxes is really unheard of on Water Island.

September 2006 9 5 4
November 2007 8 4 4
September 2008 17 10 7
October 2009 20 13 7
August 2010 35 25 10
August 2011 24 17 7
May 2012 27 16 10
August 2013 22 15 7
March 2015 18 6 11
September 2016 21 9 12
April 2019 15 4 11
Note This section is dated April 2019; prices, property estimates and numbers reflect the market at the time this section was updated. Information is believed to be accurate but not guaranteed.
Close Menu