There are a bunch on the North side like the Sugar Bay Wyndam, Point Pleasant, Sapphire Beach, and there is one that I can't remember for the life of me....but it's all little suites with their own pools. The other way, towards Estate Nazareth are the Ritz Carlton, the Elysian, Secret Harbour...and a little further is Bolongo. Those are all close to Duffy's. Woody's is on St John, but staying at the same hotels I mentioned puts you fairly close to the Ferry Dock to Cruz Bay (it's basically across the street from Duffy's), and Woody's is walking distance from there.

Enjoy!

Tamrind Inn is within walking of both Woody's and Duffy's

Have fun!